Moral dillema

In August I purchase a BAT (25th) off of eBay. Week goes by, not marked shipped. Another week goes by, finally marked shipped. Week and a half goes by tracking numbers are added. Week later, message seller. No response. Start a claim with eBay, still wanted item. eBay rules in my favor and refunded my money.

I figured that was that. Figure never shipped. Seller didn’t care, life goes on, so it goes.

Four days later, BAT shows up. Haven’t had a dumbfounded face like that in a long while.

I contact eBay, so I figure out how to pay buyer. They were dumbfounded that someone would actually call after eBay ruled in their favor and still received the item. They, after they had to actually ask around(I could hear them talking the background), found out that I would need to contact the seller to resend me an invoice. The seller agreed to resend the invoice so I could pay. I’ve left the BAT in it’s packaging.

It’s been a month since I received the BAT. A month since I contacted the seller. It’s still in the packaging.

Do I open it?